Statistics from Altmetric.com
Stroke may disrupt breathing either by (A) causing a disturbance of central rhythm generation, (B) interrupting the descending respiratory pathways leading to a reduced respiratory drive, or (C) causing bulbar weakness leading to aspiration.
Pathophysiology of respiratory control in stroke
Neural control of respiration in man depends on a central drive to the respiratory muscles which is modulated by chemical and mechanical inputs.1 While many of the factors controlling established respiratory rhythm in mammals are understood, the neural mechanisms of rhythm generation remain obscure.2-4 It has proved difficult, in man, to attribute precise respiratory function to localised anatomical substrates because lesions are rarely localised and coexisting pulmonary, cardiovascular, or autonomic influences may complicate the clinical picture. Furthermore accurate diagnosis of respiratory insufficiency has led to earlier therapeutic intervention with controlled ventilation. Also there is probably considerable redundancy and plasticity of the neural substrate of respiratory control, thus congenital, longstanding, or slowly progressive and destructive mass lesions can have little or no functional consequence while acute discrete lesions in a similar distribution may lead to profound respiratory impairment. Finally much of the literature is flawed because the extensive experimental animal work has been applied to man without any evidence for anatomicophysiological correlates. However in individual case studies abnormalities of respiration may be associated with small, discrete lesions of the central nervous system, defined by imaging or postmortem, particularly due to stroke. Such reports have complemented experimental animal work and have greatly increased our understanding of the mechanisms that control breathing in man.
Central respiratory drive is mediated by three pathways, which are largely anatomically and functionally independent above the segmental level,1 although it is increasingly clear that these systems must interact with one another to some extent.5 6
METABOLIC (AUTOMATIC) RESPIRATION
Metabolic (automatic) respiration is the homoeostatic pathway by which ventilation may be mediated to maintain acid-base status and oxygenation to the metabolic requirements. Automatic control is mediated by localised areas in the dorsolateral tegmentum of the pons and medulla in the region of the nucleus tractus solitarius and nucleus retroambigualis (for review see Howard and Hirsch7). As a consequence of lesions in this area automatic respiratory control is disrupted; the patient is voluntarily able to maintain his respiratory pattern and breathes normally while awake and alert but during sleep there is a sudden or progressive decline in tidal volume and respiratory rate culminating in central apnoea.
Abnormal patterns of rate and rhythm are also often a reflection of impaired automatic ventilatory control.8 Primary central neurogenic hyperventilationis a rare condition characterised by rapid, regular hyperventilation which persists in the face of alkalosis, raised oxygen tension, low carbon dioxide tension, and in the absence of any pulmonary or airway disorder.9 10 However,hyperventilation in the post-stroke patient is common but is due to intrinsic pulmonary involvement.11-13 In apneusticbreathing there are sustained inspiratory cramps with a prolonged pause at full inspiration or alternating brief end inspiratory and expiratory pauses. The pattern has been associated with bilateral tegmental infarcts in the pons. Ataxic respiration is characterised by a completely irregular respiratory cycle of variable frequency and tidal volume alternating with periods of apnoea. It is particularly associated with medullary impairment either due to brainstem stroke or compression due to rapidly expanding lesions and may be an important sign of impending respiratory arrest. Hiccups consist of brief bursts of intense inspiratory activity involving the diaphragm and inspiratory intercostal muscles with reciprocal inhibition of the expiratory intercostals.14 15 Glottic closure occurs almost immediately after the onset of diaphragmatic contraction thus minimising the ventilatory effect. Intractable hiccups may be the result of structural or functional disturbances of the medulla or its afferent or efferent connections with the respiratory muscles This may be associated with structural lesions of the medulla including infarction in the territory of the posterior inferior cerebellar artery. The development of hiccups in this context may anticipate the development of irregularities of the respiratory rhythm culminating in respiratory arrest.
BEHAVIOURAL (VOLUNTARY) RESPIRATION
Behavioural (voluntary) respiration operates during wakefulness and allows voluntary modulation of respiration in response, for example, to speaking, singing, breath holding, and straining. Volitional control is active during consciousness but quiescent during sleep, although it may be involved in the chaotic respiratory patterns seen during rapid eye movement sleep. Voluntary control may be impaired by bilateral lesions affecting the descending corticospinal or corticobulbar tracts,5 and is particularly seen in association with destructive vascular lesions of the basal pons or of the medullary pyramids and adjacent ventromedial portion which may result in the “locked in” syndrome.16 Selective interruption of the voluntary pathways in man leads to a strikingly regular and unvarying respiratory pattern during wakefulness as well as sleep, with loss of the ability to take a deep breath, hold the breath, cough voluntarily, or initiate any kind of volitional respiratory movement. The tidal volume remains responsive to carbon dioxide and a reflex cough is preserved.17 Diffuse cortical vascular disease may lead to selective abnormalities of voluntary breathing such that there is an inability to take a deep breath or to hold the breath to command. These respiratory apraxias may be associated with inability to initiate voluntary swallowing or with other behavioural apraxias.1 18 Cheyne-Stokes respiration is characterised by a smooth waxing and waning of breath volume and frequency separated by periods of apnoea19 20; the hyperpnoeic phase is longer than the apnoea and the entire cycle typically lasts one minute or more. The respiratory oscillations are associated with phasic changes in cerebral blood flow, cerebrospinal fluid pressure, arterial and alveolar oxygen and carbon dioxide, level of alertness and pupillary size; periodic heart block and ventricular arrhythmias are also common. It has been suggested that Cheyne-Stokes respiration may occur in up to 50% of patients after unilateral supratentorial stroke21 22 and, despite the observations of Plum and Posner, it may also be common after infratentorial stroke. Studies in these patients show the frequency variations of respiratory amplitude modulation is low suggesting that Cheyne-Stokes respiration represents a relatively uniform response to central nervous system injury regardless of infarct size or location. During Cheyne-Stokes respiration there are concomitant periodic drops in arterial oxygen saturation compromising the vulnerable hypoperfused peri-infarct tissue of the ischaemic penumbra.
LIMBIC (EMOTIONAL) RESPIRATION
Limbic (emotional) respiration accounts for the preservation of respiratory modulation to emotional stimuli including laughing, coughing, and anxiety despite loss of voluntary control. This implies that descending limbic influences on automatic respiration are anatomically and functionally independent of the voluntary respiratory system. Munschauer et aldescribed a patient with locked in syndrome due to infarction of the basal pons, this led to loss of voluntary control but carbon dioxide responses remained normal.23 This patient showed preserved respiratory modulation to emotional stimuli including coughing and anxiety and in another patient laughing.17 Such an independent descending pathway, mediating limbic control of respiration lies either in the pontine tegmentum or lateral basis pontis. Such limbic pathways are also suggested by the effect of limbic cortex stimulation and epileptic seizures.
Patterns of respiratory impairment due to stroke
Hemispheric ischaemic strokes influence respiratory function to a modest degree. Reductions of both chest wall and diaphragm excursion contralateral to the stroke have been reported.24 25 The latter association correlates well with the localisation of the diaphragm cortical representation found by transcranial magnetic stimulation and positron emission tomography scanning.26-31 At present there is no clear evidence of cerebral dominance for diaphragm function.
Patients with bilateral hemispheric cerebrovascular disease show an increased respiratory responsiveness to carbon dioxide and are liable to develop Cheyne-Stokes respiration suggesting disinhibition of lower respiratory centres. Such a response may persist months to years after the stroke. Diffuse cortical vascular disease may also lead to a selective inability of voluntary breathing (respiratory apraxia).18 Intermittent upper airway obstruction and apnoea due to periodic fluctuations in the position of the vocal cords is associated with cortical supranuclear palsy due to bilateral lesions of the operculum.32
The effects of brainstem dysfunction on respiration depend on the pathology, localisation, and speed of onset of the lesion. In patients with bulbar lesions, particularly vascular, the combination of impaired swallow, abnormalities of the respiratory rhythm, reduced vital capacity, and reduced or absent triggering of cough reflex all increase the risk of aspiration pneumonia.33 Nocturnal upper airway occlusion may also contribute to respiratory impairment. Unilateral or bilateral lateral tegmental infarcts in the pons (at or below the level of the trigeminal nucleus) may lead to apneustic breathing and impairment of carbon dioxide responsiveness,34 while similar lesions in the medulla (for example, lateral medullary syndrome) may result in acute failure of the automatic respiration.35 36 Infarction of the basal pons (locked in syndrome) or of the pyramids and the adjacent ventromedial portion of the medulla may lead to complete loss of the voluntary system with a highly regular breathing pattern but a complete inability to initiate any spontaneous respiratory movements.37
Acute vascular lesions in the lower brainstem compromise respiratory control, particularly during sleep, leading to irregularities of rate and rhythm of breathing which lead to Cheyne-Stokes respiration, hypopnoea, and obstructive apnoea.38 39 It is likely that size and bilaterality of the lesions determine the type and severity of abnormalities of the respiratory pattern. In a series of 15 patients with vascular lesions of the lower brainstem, patients with unilateral lesions in the rostrolateral medulla showed a reduced ventilatory sensitivity to inhaled carbon dioxide. In these patients there was a minimal effect on breathing while awake, at rest or during exertion, however there was a high incidence of fragmented sleep and obstructive sleep apnoea associated with hypoxaemia. The authors concluded that patients with unilateral rostrolateral medullary lesions require monitoring during sleep to diagnose sleep apnoea.38
Isolated central sleep apnoea due to brainstem vascular disease is usually associated with bilateral lesions caudal to the V cranial nerve in the pons down to the ventral lateral, tegmental pons, medulla, and cervical spinal cord. Occasional reports have described central apnoea with unilateral lesions involving nucleus ambiguus but sparing nucleus tractus solitarius; however the relevance of these is difficult to assess with limited respiratory, imaging, and neuropathological information.39
Infarction of the spinal cord at high cervical levels may selectively affect respiratory control.40 41 Lesions of the anterior pathways, particularly descending reticulospinal, lead to loss of automatic control and sudden nocturnal death from apnoea while involvement of the dorsolateral corticospinal tracts may lead to automatic respiration of the type described earlier. Infarction of the spinal cord at high cervical levels is usually due to occlusion of the anterior spinal artery and may be due to fibrocartilaginous embolism.42 Patients may present with neck or shoulder pain but then develop a rapidly evolving tetraplegia and respiratory insufficiency culminating in respiratory arrest. Complete anterior spinal artery occlusion causing infarction that extends up to C1 has a poor outlook, while incomplete occlusion at C3/4 may show significant recovery of respiratory and limb function.43
Respiration is commonly affected after stroke and the pattern of breathing may reflect the aetiology, localisation, and severity of the underlying cerebrovascular disease. However, the extent to which abnormal patterns of breathing after stroke may be of prognostic significance and the optimum management of post-stroke ventilatory sufficiency remain uncertain.
Funding of the South London Stroke Register from the NHS Executive, Northern and Yorkshire Region, UK, Cardiovascular Disease and Stroke programme.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.