Largyngotracheal and pharyngoesophageal tears following minor blunt trauma to the neck are uncommon. A child with such an injury is reported and the modes of diagnosis and management are discussed. Patients may initially present with minimal signs and symptoms, but their condition may deteriorate rapidly or insidiously. In the absence of respiratory compromise, conservative management is appropriate, but all patients with significant blunt neck trauma should undergo early direct laryngoscopy under a general anaesthetic.
- blunt injury
Statistics from Altmetric.com
A 4-year-old girl fell forwards onto the backrest of a wooden chair, causing minor pain to the neck and upper chest. Although initially well, 4 hours later she was taken to Mayday Hospital with neck swelling and hoarseness. On examination there was marked surgical emphysema over the neck and chest extending to the sixth rib (figure1). There was no bruising or stridor and the trachea was central. The larynx was normal on palpation and there was no dysphagia. Oxygen saturations remained normal on air. A chest X-ray demonstrated a pneumomediastinum (figure 2).
The child was transferred to St George's Hospital where flexible fibreoptic laryngoscopy revealed moderate swelling of the supraglottis without pooling of saliva. A thoracic opinion was obtained and the clinical findings were suggested to be compatible with barotrauma to the oesophagus resulting in a pinhole perforation. The child was monitored on the paediatric ITU overnight and kept nil by mouth. The following day she remained well and apyrexial. There was some resolution of the surgical emphysema and she was commenced on clear fluids and later a soft diet. She was subsequently discharged without complication.
Minor blunt trauma to the neck and upper chest in children is common, but significant injury to the pharynx, larynx, trachea or oesophagus is unusual. However, cases of laryngotracheal and pharyngoesophageal tears from relatively minor blunt trauma have been documented in the literature.
Children have a proportionally large mandible and short neck in comparison with adults. In addition, a child's soft and pliable laryngeal and tracheal cartilages can probably sustain greater temporary force than the adolescent or adult airway, a child's non-calcified larynx being more likely to recoil to its original position without fracturing. Despite protective mechanisms, however, with the neck extended, a midline blow can exert excessive force on the larynx and trachea, crushing the trachea against the posterior vertebral column, with tearing of the posterior membraneous wall of the trachea, resulting in air being forced into the retropharynx and mediastinum.1
Cervical oesophageal perforation secondary to minor blunt trauma is extremely rare. Barotrauma resulting from a compressive thoracic injury is the proposed hypothesis for this injury. The rapid rise in oesophageal pressure can exceed the tensile strength of the oesophagus leading to perforation. The mechanism for barometric perforation of the distended, hollow viscus of the oesophagus has been well documented.2-4 An anatomic weakness at the hypopharyngeal–oesophageal junction (Killian's dehiscence) predisposes this area to perforation. With a blow or fall against the neck and upper chest, the upper airway may be sealed off at the hyoid level. Simultaneously the thoracic cavity is emptied of its inspired air. If these barometric forces exceed the bursting pressure of the hypopharyngeal–oesophageal junction, perforation results, with the compressed air from the lungs being forced through the ruptured pharynx into the fascial planes of the neck. The literature shows that most oesophageal perforations secondary to blunt trauma occur at this level.2 5 6
The most common cause of acute laryngeal trauma in adults is blunt injury, especially from road traffic accidents, followed by sports injuries, falls and assaults, with victims of road traffic accidents usually presenting with the most severe trauma.7 8 In children, falls from bicycles and playground equipment-related accidents are the most common cause of blunt neck injuries.9 These generally insignificant injuries in children rarely result in serious harm and parents and healthcare workers sometimes discount early warning signs. Patients may present with minimal signs and symptoms, but their condition may deteriorate rapidly or insidiously. External signs of injury are usually minimal and local bruising or swelling may be absent. The child is assessed for airway compromise but often the only sign of significant upper aerodigestive tract injury will be the presence of surgical emphysema. A tear of the upper aerodigestive tract, somewhere in the larynx, trachea, hypopharynx or oesophagus, must be assumed in the presence of surgical emphysema.10 It should be noted that the site and extent of cervical surgical emphysema do not necessarily indicate the anatomical site of injury.
The most common symptoms of a laryngotracheal tear at presentation are hoarseness (including dysphonia and/or aphonia), stridor and surgical emphysema9 and of a pharyngoesophageal tear, dysphagia, odynophagia, dyspnoea, hoarseness and surgical emphysema.11 It is important to exercise a high index of suspicion and consider a laryngotracheal or pharyngoesophageal tear in any child presenting with these symptoms following a seemingly minor blunt trauma to the neck or chest. A lateral soft-tissue neck X-ray and chest X-ray will disclose the presence of free retropharyngeal and subcutaneous air, pneumomediastinum or pneumothorax. A computed tomographic scan of the neck and chest and a contrast swallow are investigations which should also be considered to further define the extent of the injury. All patients with significant blunt neck trauma should undergo early and meticulous direct laryngoscopy under a general anaesthetic. Rigid oesophagoscopy and rigid bronchoscopy should also be considered. In the absence of respiratory compromise, conservative management with close nursing observation, preferably on a paediatric intensive care unit, is appropriate.
minor blunt cervical trauma can lead to significant laryngotracheal and pharyngoesophageal injury, although this is uncommon
patients need to be properly assessed and monitored for airway compromise as their condition may deteriorate after presenting with a seemingly insignificant injury
hoarseness, stridor, dyspnoea, dysphagia and odynophagia are important symptoms to look for
surgical emphysema is often the only presenting sign
patients presenting with a minor blunt cervical trauma should have a lateral soft-tissue neck X-ray and chest X-ray. This will disclose the presence of surgical emphysema, pneumomediastinum or pneumothorax
conservative management is appropriate in the absence of respiratory compromise, but endoscopic assessment under a general anaesthetic needs to be undertaken if there is any suspicion of more serious injury