Article Text

PDF

Carotid and vertebral artery dissection syndromes
  1. B Thanvi1,
  2. S K Munshi2,
  3. S L Dawson2,
  4. T G Robinson3
  1. 1Department of Integrated Medicine, Leicester General Hospital, University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust, Leicester, UK
  2. 2Department of Stroke Medicine, Leicester General Hospital
  3. 3Leicester Warwick Medical School, Leicester General Hospital
  1. Correspondence to:
 Dr B Thanvi
 Department of Integrated Medicine, Leicester General Hospital, Gwendolen Road, University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust, Leicester LE5 4PW, UK; bthanvihotmail.com

Abstract

Cervicocerebral arterial dissections (CAD) are an important cause of strokes in younger patients accounting for nearly 20% of strokes in patients under the age of 45 years. Extracranial internal carotid artery dissections comprise 70%–80% and extracranial vertebral dissections account for about 15% of all CAD. Aetiopathogenesis of CAD is incompletely understood, though trauma, respiratory infections, and underlying arteriopathy are considered important. A typical picture of local pain, headache, and ipsilateral Horner’s syndrome followed after several hours by cerebral or retinal ischaemia is rare. Doppler ultrasound, MRI/MRA, and CT angiography are useful non-invasive diagnostic tests. The treatment of extracranial CAD is mainly medical using anticoagulants or antiplatelet agents although controlled studies to show their effectiveness are lacking. The prognosis of extracranial CAD is generally much better than that of the intracranial CAD. Recurrences are rare in CAD.

  • CAD, cervicocerbral arterial dissection
  • ICD, internal carotid dissection
  • VAD, vertebral artery dissection
  • EICD, extracranial internal carotid artery dissection
  • dissection
  • internal carotid artery
  • vertebral artery

Statistics from Altmetric.com

The term dissection implies a tear in the wall of a major artery leading to the intrusion of blood within the layers of an arterial wall (intramural haematoma). This causes stenosis of the lumen when blood collects between the intima and media or an aneurysmal dilatation of the artery when the haematoma predominantly involves the media and adventitia. Once thought to be rare, cervicocerebral arterial dissections (CADs) have been increasingly recognised as a cause of stroke, particularly in young people. It was the work of Fisher et al in the late 1970s that led to the recognition of the clinical and radiological features of dissection syndromes facilitating their antemortem diagnosis.1 Among CADs, internal carotid artery dissections (ICDs) are much more common than vertebral dissections. The aetiopathogenesis of CAD is not fully understood. A history of preceding neck trauma is common although not universal. Heritable connective disorders such as Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, Marfan’s syndrome, α1 antitrypsin deficiency, etc, may predispose to CAD.

Typical clinical features of CAD include unilateral neck pain, headache, ipsilateral Horner’s syndrome followed by manifestations of the cerebral or ocular ischaemia and cranial nerve palsies. The CAD can cause neurological deficits either because of haemodynamic failure (caused by luminal stenosis) or by an artery to artery thromboembolism. Catheter angiography had been the method of choice to diagnose arterial dissections, but with the advent of Doppler ultrasonography, MRI/MRA, and CT angiography, most dissections can now be diagnosed non-invasively. The treatment of symptomatic CAD is essentially medical and neurosurgical interventions are rarely required. As thromboembolism is the most probable mechanism behind any neurological deficit, anticoagulants (heparin and warfarin) and antiplatetelets are commonly used, although there have not been any randomised studies to evaluate their effectiveness. The prognosis depends on the severity of neurological deficit but is generally good in extracranial dissections. The recurrence rate of CAD is very low. This review focuses on the pathogenesis, clinical features, diagnosis, and medical treatment of these syndromes.

EPIDEMIOLOGY

Although reported in all age groups, CADs are most common between the ages of 35 and 50 years, with a peak incidence in the fifth decade.2 They account for up to 20% of strokes in patients under the age of 45 years.3 A community based study showed an incidence of cervicocerebral dissections of 2.6 per 100 000 per year.4 However, cervicocerebral dissections may be asymptomatic or may cause only minor symptoms and therefore, their true incidence is difficult to ascertain. The incidence of CADs is non-significantly higher in women. Trauma during forceps delivery can cause CAD in neonates.

CLASSIFICATION OF CERVICOCEREBRAL DISSECTION SYNDROMES

CADs include ICDs and vertebral artery dissections (VADs). In each arterial system, the segment of the artery involved can be extracranial (dissection involving the artery in the neck before it enters the cranium) or intracranial (when dissections affect the intracranial part of the artery) (box). ICD are at least three times commoner than VAD. The clinical features in these two types are distinct in view of the different areas of brain supplied by the two arteries. Dissections tend to affect extracranial segments of the arteries much more commonly than intracranial segments. However, intracranial dissections are usually more severe and carry a poorer prognosis than extracranial dissections. The increased incidence of extracranial involvement has been explained by the fact that this segment of the artery is more mobile and is also prone to damage by bony structures such as the vertebrae and styloid processes.5

The site predilection for CAD is quite different from that of atherosclerosis affecting the cervical arteries. Dissection involves the pharyngeal and distal parts of the internal carotid artery, whereas atherosclerosis usually affects the origin and the carotid bulb. Similarly, dissections affect distal parts of the extracranial vertebral artery, whereas atherosclerosis tends to involve the proximal segments

AETIOPATHOGENESIS OF CAD

The pathogenesis of CAD is not fully understood. The following discussion outlines the current views on this subject.

Where does the dissection start in the artery?

An arterial wall consists of three layers—intima (the innermost layer), media (the middle muscular layer), and adventitia (the outermost layer). It is generally agreed that a tear in the wall of an artery leads to a collection of blood between the layers of the artery, leading to formation of an intramural haematoma. However, there is no universal agreement as to which wall is the primary site of dissection. Some authorities consider a rupture within the connective tissue and vasa vasorum of the media as the most probable initial event in dissection.6 The intramural haematoma may then later penetrate the intima and reconnect with the true arterial lumen. Others think that an intimal tear occurs,7 which allows blood under arterial pressure to enter the wall of the artery.

Intimal tears are not always easy to diagnose on pathological specimens. Even in the carefully selected patients it is not always possible to show a communication between the intramural haematoma (the so called false lumen) and the true lumen, suggesting that some dissections of carotid and vertebral arteries may be caused by a primary intramural haematoma.

What are the causes/triggers of a CAD?

Several factors have been proposed as causative or trigger factors for arterial dissections.

Trauma

Cervicocerebral dissections are often preceded by some form of trauma to the neck. However, the severity of trauma can range from a trivial injury (for example, vigorous nose blowing) to severe roadside accidents involving direct injury to the neck arteries. Practically all forms of neck trauma have been reported to be associated with CAD including chiropractic manoeuvres, vigorous coughing or nose blowing, sudden neck turning as in reversing a car, prolonged telephone conversations, road accidents inflicting direct trauma to a cervical artery, strangulations, bar fights, recent surgery involving prolonged anaesthesia, etc.

It is conceivable that trauma leads to a tear in the intima or media. However, it is difficult to explain how minor neck trauma can cause dissection of the arteries and in many cases there is no clear history of antecedent trauma in some cases.

Common types of cervicocerebral dissections

  • Internal carotid artery dissection

    • – extracranial dissections

    • – intracranial dissections

  • Vertebral artery dissections

    • – extracranial dissections

    • – intracranial dissections

Genetic factors

Several inherited disorders of connective tissue are known to be associated with CAD although in practice they are rarely found. Most typical of these is vascular Ehler-Danlos syndrome (EDS), an autosomal dominant disorder. Patients with this disorder often carry mutations in the gene that encodes pro-α1 (III) collagen.8 Brandt et al showed ultrastructural abnormalities of dermal connective tissue components in two thirds of patients with spontaneous dissection of the carotid or vertebral artery but with no other stigmata of a known connective tissue disorder.9 CADs have also been reported in association with fibromuscular dysplasia, a non-inflammatory disease of medium sized arteries mainly affecting the carotid and renal arteries.10 Patients with ICD are more likely to have fibromuscular dysplasia than patients with VAD.11

α1 Antitrypsin deficiency12 and abnormalities of neural crest cells, such as angiolipomatosis and lentigenosis13,14 have also been associated with an increased risk of CAD. In about 5% of patients with CAD, there is a family history of spontaneous arterial dissections.15 To date no mutations in the gene for type III procollagen (COL3A1) have been identified.16 The CAD has also been reported in patients with osteogenesis imperfecta.17

Interestingly, hyperhomocysteinaemia has recently been reported to be an in association with CAD18; Pezzini et al report higher levels of fasting total plasma homocysteine (tHcy) in patients with spontaneous CAD (13.2 µmol/l; range, 7 to 32.8 µmol/l) compared with control subjects (8.9 µmol/l; range, 5 to 17.3 µmol/l).19 The authors also noted a significant association between the MTHFRT (methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase) genotype and spontaneous CAD. A mutation in the coding region of MTHFRT is associated with a variant form of the enzyme that has a reduced level of activity. The authors suggest several possible biological mechanisms to explain the relation between the increased plasma homocysteine concentrations and arterial dissections. These include increased elastolytic activity and inhibition of the cross linking of collagen caused by hyperhomocysteinaemia.The detailed account of the biochemical mechanisms underlying association of hyperhomocysteinaemia and CAD is beyond the scope of this article and the reader is referred to a recent article by Rosner on this subject.20

The occasional association of spontaneous dissections with intracranial aneurysms21 and arterial redundancies (for example, coils, kinks, and loops) also supports the theory of an underlying arteriopathy.22 Recently, some authors have reported an evidence of impaired endothelium dependent vasodilatation in CAD patients that is not the result of stroke, and they suggest that an underlying abnormality of the arterial wall layers may predispose to CAD.23 However, the theory of an underlying arteriopathy fails to explain the specific site predilection of dissections, their low recurrence rate, and the rarity of a family history in CAD. It is possible that in the familial cases, the penetrance of the genetic predisposition is low.

Infections

A recent infection (particularly a respiratory infection) has been suggested by some authors to predispose to the CAD.24 In a case controlled study,25 an acute infection was more frequent in patients with the spontaneous CAD (31.9%) than in control subjects (13.5%) This association was stronger in patients with multiple (odds ratio, 6.4) rather than single artery (odds ratio, 2.1) dissection. The damage to the arterial wall may be caused by proteolytic, oxidative, or autoimmune mechanisms. This theory is also supported by the finding of seasonal variations in the incidence of CAD, with the highest incidence in the fall.26 However, no direct evidence exists for a specific infectious agent.

Miscellaneous factors

CAD has also been reported in associations with migraine,27 smoking, hypertension, and contraceptive use.

In summary, the pathogenesis of CAD presumably entails an interaction of genetic and environmental factors (fig 1).

Figure 1

 Schema of interaction of genetic and environmental factors in the pathogenesis of cervicocerebral dissections.

What is the mechanism of neurological deficit(s)?

Local thrombus formation is promoted by the luminal stenosis and the release of thrombogenic factors by the intimal damage. Cerebral ischaemia can be produced by (1) a narrowed lumen with the consequent haemadynamic failure or, (2) embolisation from local thrombus, or both. Embolisation seems to be the main mechanism as suggested by (1) the detection of distal emboli on angiography in patients with CAD, (2) the evidence of microemboli signals on Doppler ultrasound in many cases, and (3) evidence of cerebral ischaemia or infarct in the absence of a significant luminal stenosis, or both. This is further corroborated by a study28 that found territorial infarcts indicative of thromboembolic disease in all 141 consecutive patients with spontaneous carotid dissections on CT, MRI, and ultrasound. Additional border zone infarcts, indicating haemodynamic infarction, were seen in six patients.

Horner’s syndrome and cranial nerve palsies (particularly the lower nerves) are the result of local dissection effects.

Clinical features of CAD

The clinical presentation of CAD depends on the artery involved and the location of the dissection, for example, extracranial compared with intracranial. Typically, CAD present as pain, headache, Horner’s syndrome, lower cranial nerve palsies, cerebral or ocular TIAs, and/or strokes. Clinical aspects of main cervicocerebral dissections are described below.

EXTRACRANIAL INTERNAL CAROTID ARTERY DISSECTIONS (EICD)

Cervical internal carotid dissections are the commonest type of CAD and account for nearly 2.5% of all first strokes.29 They occur most commonly between the ages of 35 and 50, affecting both sexes equally. The classic triad of pain on one side of the head, face, or neck, partial Horner’s syndrome followed hours or days later by cerebral or retinal ischaemia is found in less than one third of patients, but the presence of any two elements of this triad is strongly suggestive of the diagnosis.7 The clinical features of EICD can be divided into two groups depending on whether they result from the local effects of the dissection or from the distal ischaemia.

Clinical manifestations attributable to local effects

Pain

Neck pain and headache are usually the most prominent features of the EICD and may be the only manifestations. They may precede cerebral or ocular ischaemic symptoms by hours or days whereas in atherosclerotic stroke headache usually accompanies or follows the onset of neurological deficit. This may provide an important differentiating clue from atherosclerotic aetiology. The pain is usually sharp and may affect the jaw or face. The headache is usually constant and non-throbbing, although severe throbbing headache, “thunderclap” headache, or gradually worsening headaches have also been reported. It mostly affects the frontal or frontoparietal area.29 Sometimes it can be confused with a migraine episode or a subarachnoid bleed.30 About two thirds of the patients report an ipsilateral headache.

Partial Horner’s syndrome

The sympathetic fibres that travel along the internal carotid artery can be affected in EICD causing Horner’s syndrome on the ipsilateral side. The syndrome is usually partial and is characterised by ptosis and miosis. There is no anhidrosis as fibres for sweat function in the face travel along the external carotid artery. Nearly 50% of EICD present with the Horner’s syndrome.31

Pulsatile tinnitus or a subjective bruit may be noted in about one third of patients.

Ipsilateral cranial nerve palsies can be a local manifestation of EICD. Any cranial nerve can be involved but lower nerves are more often implicated. Isolated palsies of the hypoglossal nerve and sixth nerve have been reported. Taste disturbance and tongue weakness are the most common manifestations and are the result of compression and ischaemia of the XII nerve because of its proximity to the carotid sheath. A combination of ipsilateral cranial nerve palsy and contralateral hemispheric deficit in EICD may mimic brain stem ischaemia and is termed a “false localising sign”.32

Clinical manifestations attributable to ischaemia

EICD may cause ipsilateral cerebral or retinal ischaemia in 40%–90% of cases.33 The ischaemic signs tend to follow local symptoms by hours to a few days. Because of the increased awareness among physicians of CAD coupled with the availability of non-invasive tests, it is probable that the dissections are now diagnosed early and in the absence of any neurological deficit.

The ischaemia may cause TIAs or infarctions, or both. Both cerebral and retinal ischaemic manifestations have been reported, including amaurosis fugax, hemiplegia, dysphasia, etc. The TIA periods are usually more frequent than in the atherosclerotic stroke, described by Fisher as carotid allegro.1 Cerebral infarctions are usually preceded by TIAs. Ischaemic optic neuropathy attributable to the occlusion of arteries supplying the optic nerve may rarely occur if the dissection extends to the carotid siphon.34

INTRACRANIAL CAROTID SYSTEM DISSECTIONS

It is important to differentiate extracranial dissection from intracranial dissection for several reasons:

  • Intracranial dissections are much less common than extracranial dissections.35 However, it is possible that because of the lack of specific angiographic features, many non-fatal intracranial dissections are not diagnosed.

  • Patients with intracranial dissections are generally younger than those with extracranial dissections, most commonly in their second or third decades.

  • Intracranial dissections are usually associated with large strokes. A mortality of 75% has been reported in these dissections.

  • Subarachnoid haemorrhage (SAH) can result from intracranial dissections, because of the extension of an intramural haematoma through the adventitia.

  • Intracranial dissections can cause aneurysmal dilatations of the arteries that may behave as space occupying lesions compressing adjacent cranial nerves or the brain.

  • Surgical interventions are more often needed in intracranial dissections.

DISSECTIONS OF VERTEBROBASILAR SYSTEM

Extracranial vertebral dissections

Neck trauma may clearly precede an extracranial vertebral dissection. The vertebral artery is most mobile and thus most vulnerable to mechanical injury at C1 to C2 as it leaves the transverse foramen of the axis vertebra and suddenly turns to enter the intracranial cavity. Women are 2.5 times more frequently affected by the extracranial vertebral dissections than men and the reverse is true for intracranial dissections.36 Clinical manifestations include severe neck pain mostly in the occipitocervical area followed after a variable interval by ischaemic symptoms. In some patients there may not be any ischaemic symptoms. Dizziness, vertigo, double vision, ataxia, and dysarthria are common clinical features. TIAs are less common than in ICA dissections. Lateral medullary (Wallenberg syndrome) and cerebellar infarctions are the most common types of strokes. Occasionally, spinal cord infarctions occur because of the involvement of branches of the extracranial vertebral artery that supply the cervical spinal cord.

Intracranial vertebral artery dissections are more common in men. More than 50% of intracranial vertebral artery dissections are associated with subarachnoid haemorrhage.37 Brain stem infarctions and aneurismal arteries presenting as space occupying lesions are other manifestations. Basilar artery dissections are very rare.

DIAGNOSIS OF CAD

A high index of clinical suspicion is required to diagnose CAD and confirmation is obtained by either Doppler ultrasonography, MRI/MRA, CT angiography, or catheter angiography.

Doppler ultrasound scanning has a diagnostic sensitivity of >90%. Continuous wave Doppler velocimetry, standard duplex scanning, and colour Doppler flow imaging have all been used in the diagnosis of carotid dissections. The common finding is that of a high resistance flow pattern in the distal arteries. Although this finding is not specific on its own, in combination with a characteristic clinical presentation and in absence of atherosclerosis it is highly suggestive of CAD.38 The pathognomonic feature of dissection, such as intramural haematoma or double lumen and intimal flap are rarely found. Transcranial Doppler can be used in diagnosis of the intracranial dissections. Doppler scanning is non-invasive, comparatively inexpensive, and is widely available. It can also be used for follow up monitoring of dissections. However, it has limitations including technical difficulties scanning the distal internal carotid artery, detecting emboli, and a lower sensitivity with dissections that cause low grade stenoses. In a study of 44 angiography confirmed dissections, continuous wave Doppler examination showed signs of severe obstruction of carotid arteries in 96% of cases (occlusion, extensive submandibular tight stenoses, significant slow down in the carotid and ophthalmic vessels, retrograde ophthalmic blood flow), standard duplex scanning suggested dissection in 72% of the cases (tapering stenoses or occlusion, segmental ectasis, tubular vessel, peripheral residual channel, or rare irregular “membrane”) and colour Doppler flow imaging suggested a dissection in 82% of the cases.38 The ultrasound failed only when it was done late and when moderate or segmental intrapetrosal dissections were present.

MRI/MRA is proving useful in diagnosing CAD. Intramural haematomas can be shown as hyperdense signals on T1 weighted imaging and characteristically have a crescent shape adjacent to the lumen. Fat suppression techniques are important to differentiate small intramural haematomas from the surrounding soft tissues. The MR scans can also show a luminal stenosis or an occlusion. With increasing experience in their use, MRI/MRA seem to be replacing catheter angiography in the diagnosis of CAD. However, the sensitivity of MRI/MRA is highest two days after dissections. MR imaging can also be used for follow up monitoring of the dissections.

CT angiography has been shown to have a very high sensitivity for CAD, but there is only limited experience with the technique. Unlike the other modalities, changes are apparent very soon after ictus.

Catheter angiography has been the traditional method of diagnosing arterial dissections. The commonest finding on angiography is the so called “string sign”—a long segment of narrowed lumen. The pathognomonic features of dissection, such as an intimal flap or a double lumen, are found in less than 10% of cases.39 The artery may show sudden tapering because of occlusion of the lumen (fig 2), aneurysmal dilatations are also found in some cases.40 Catheter angiography is an invasive test and carries a risk of stroke of between 0.5% and 1%.41 It is losing its “gold standard” status as the resolution of MR angiography now approaches that of a conventional angiography, and MRI can show the intramural haematoma itself.

Figure 2

 Carotid angiogram showing tapering of the blood flow in the left internal carotid artery because of the dissection.

TREATMENT OF CAD

Asymptomatic CADs do not require any intervention. The treatment of symptomatic extracranial dissections is essentially medical. The rationale of treatment in CAD is to prevent thrombus formation on the injured endothelial surface and avoid artery to artery embolism.42 Once a complete occlusion has occurred, the artery does not recanalise. Anticoagulants and antiplatelet agents are commonly used in the treatment of CADs. A recent Cochrane review of the use of antithrombotic drugs (antiplatelet drugs, anticoagulants) in the treatment of extracranial carotid dissections concluded that there were no randomised trials comparing either anticoagulants or antiplatelet drugs with control.43 There is, therefore, no evidence to support their routine use in the treatment of extracranial internal carotid artery dissection, nor have the reported non-randomised studies shown any evidence of a significant difference between the anticoagulants therapy and antiplatelets.

Based on some open label studies and personal experience, several authorities favour anticoagulation with heparin followed by warfarin therapy as a reasonable approach in symptomatic CADs.42,44–46 In a recent one year follow up study, patients who were treated with aspirin had higher event rates (TIAs, stroke, or death) compared with patients treated with anticoagulants (12.4% compared with 8.3%).47 However, the difference was statistically non-significant. There are no data from controlled studies on the safety of heparin, although several consecutive series showed no significant side effects48,49 and transcranial Doppler monitoring showed decreased frequencies of high intensity transient signals with heparin treatment.50 In a study of the treatment of a blunt carotid artery injury, anticoagulation was found to be the treatment of choice where dissection or pseudoaneurysm was diagnosed.51 When anticoagulation therapy is used, it is continued until the luminal stenosis improves. After an initial period of a few weeks of treatment, anticoagulants may be substituted with antiplatelet agents (for example, aspirin, clopidogrel), and these can also be used as an initial treatment in patients with contraindications to anticoagulation. Several studies have shown the usefulness of the Doppler ultrasound in follow up monitoring of CADs.48,52 There is certainly an urgent need for a large randomised controlled trial comparing the efficacy and safety of anticoagulants and antiplatelets in CAD.

SURGICAL TREATMENT OF CAD

An urgent surgical intervention may be required in patients presenting with subarachnoid haemorrhage. Symptomatic aneurismal dilatation of the artery may also warrant surgery. Chronic carotid dissections have also been treated by surgical reconstruction to prevent further ischaemic or thromboembolic complications, if medical treatment with six month anticoagulation fails or if carotid aneurysms and/or high grade stenosis persist.53 Surgical interventions include endovascular treatment and the arterial repair.

Prognosis

Extracranial CADs generally carry a good prognosis. A literature review reports 50% of cases having no neurological deficit, 21% mild deficits only, and 25% moderate to severe deficits, the remaining 4% having died.54 In a recent Italian study looking at the relation between recanalisation rate and neurological outcome, no relation was found between these two variables,55 the neurological outcome was dependent on the lesion localisation and the presence of good collaterals.

Intracranial dissections are usually associated with severe neurological deficits or subarachnoid bleed and carry a poor prognosis. The recurrence rate for CAD is usually low. Higher recurrence rates have been noted in the immediate post-dissection period and CAD associated with familial disorders of connective tissue. There is no evidence to suggest that anticoagulation or antiplatelet therapy prevents recurrence of CAD.

REFERENCES

View Abstract

Footnotes

  • Funding: none.

  • Conflicts of interest: none declared.

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.