The long term results of midodrine treatment in a patient having debilitating chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) are reported. Midodrine treatment, directed at the autonomic nervous system, resulted in correction of the dysautonomia followed by improvement of fatigue. This finding is consistent with the hypothesis that dysautonomia plays a major part in the pathophysiology of CFS and that therapies directed at the autonomic nervous system may be effective in the treatment of CFS.
- chronic fatigue syndrome
- tilt test
- CFS, chronic fatigue syndrome
- HIS, haemodynamic instability score
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Clinically evaluated, medically unexplained fatigue of at least six months’ duration, that is of new onset, is not a result of ongoing exertion, not substantially alleviated by rest, and substantially reducing previous levels of activity is called chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS).1 The diagnosis of CFS is based on patient history and exclusion of other diagnosable medical or psychiatric illnesses. Many therapies have been suggested in CFS but none has been found to be consistently effective.2
The pathogenesis of CFS is poorly understood. A close connection between impairment of autonomic functions and CFS has been demonstrated, and can be assessed with the head-up tilt test.3 Since dysautonomic cardiovascular reactivity is frequently present in CFS patients, we hypothesised that therapies directed at the autonomic nervous system may also improve fatigue symptoms.
A 26 year old man was referred to the CFS clinic, complaining of fatigue with sudden onset eight months before, associated with headache, unrefreshing sleep, sore throat, enlarged palpable submandibular lymph nodes, diffuse muscle discomfort, and joint pain. The fatigue was substantially reducing his previous levels of occupational, educational, social, and personal activities. Body temperature was normal. The patient was not taking medications or illicit drugs. There were normal findings on physical examination and routine laboratory tests; thyroid stimulating hormone, serological tests for hepatitis B and C, HIV, Epstein-Barr virus and cytomegalovirus, chest radiography, abdominal ultrasound, electrocardiography, and echocardiography were also normal. Psychiatric examination did not reveal a past or current disorder. The diagnosis of CFS was established based on the Centers for Disease Control definition criteria.1 The fatigue severity was 22 out of a maximum 33 points according to the modified Chalder fatigue severity scale.4 A standard head-up tilt test showed normal cardiovascular reactivity by classical criteria; however, the calculated haemodynamic instability score (HIS) +2.2 was pathological (fig 1). Prior studies showed that patients with CFS usually exhibit a HIS greater than −0.98.5,6 The patient agreed to enter a therapeutic trial with midodrine HCl, a potent (α-1-adrenergic agonist).7 Oral midodrine treatment was started, 2.5 mg twice daily. At two week intervals, fatigue severity questionnaires were administered and the head-up tilt test repeated. The dose of midodrine was increased until his HIS was less than −0.98. Subsequent visits were scheduled at two month intervals. The patient’s course is illustrated in fig 2. After three months of treatment (visit 6 in fig 2), while taking 7.5 mg midodrine daily, the HIS was −1.98 (within normal range). Significant remission of fatigue occurred a few weeks later and the patient returned to regular activities. Two months later the patient underwent surgery for perforated duodenal ulcer. Midodrine treatment was discontinued. Recovery from surgery was uneventful, however, fatigue became disturbing and HIS +8.29 was noted (visit 8 in fig 2). Ten mg midodrine daily was prescribed, and was followed by normalisation of the HIS and remission of fatigue. At this time, the patient’s activities included jogging for 10 km. Three months later, in an attempt to taper midodrine, the HIS increased, while the patient was free of symptoms. The previous 10 mg dose was resumed. One year later another attempt to taper midodrine was associated with recurrence of fatigue and abnormal HIS (visit 14 in fig 2). Currently, the patient is taking 10 mg midodrine daily and is free of symptoms.
The observations regarding this patient may shed light on three issues: the role of dysautonomia in the pathogenesis of CFS, the role of autonomic testing in the diagnosis of CFS, and the possibility of treating CFS by drugs that act on the autonomic nervous system.
In CFS, abnormalities of central nervous activity have been demonstrated on magnetic resonance imaging and single photon emission tomography,8 disruption of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis and serotoninergic and noradrenergic pathways have been demonstrated, and a “distal dysautonomia” has been described.9 Blood pressure and heart rate measurements during orthostatic challenge can be used as one measure of cardiovascular autonomic activity as the fast response of blood pressure and heart rate to acute stimuli is under autonomic nervous control. For this purpose, the head-up tilt test is used. Classical pathological reactions to the head-up tilt test are: vasodepressor reaction, cardioinhibitory reaction, orthostatic hypotension, and postural tachycardia syndrome.3,9 In studies utilising these outcome measures, evidence for abnormal cardiovascular reactivity was found in one half of CFS patients.3,5,9 The latter measures are non-specific, however, also occurring in a variety of disorders unrelated to CFS. A method, recently proposed for the study of the cardiovascular reactivity of CFS patients involves computing changes in blood pressure and heart rate during the course of a head-up tilt test, followed by processing the data by image analysis methods. These data receive numerical expression as the HIS.5,6 According to results of our previous study, the best cut off differentiating CFS from healthy is HIS −0.98. HIS values greater than −0.98 are usually associated with CFS (sensitivity 90.3% and specificity 84.5%). The reproducibility of the HIS was validated with reference to the −0.98 cut off.6
Many therapies have been suggested in CFS: amantadine, doxycycline, acyclovir, immune serum globulin, dialysable leucocyte extract, interferons, fluorocortisone, cimetidine, ranitidine, magnesium, primrose oil, vitamin B12, Ampligen, essential fatty acids, liver extract, exclusive diets, and removal of dental fillings. A systematic review of 350 studies revealed that only cognitive behaviour therapy and graded exercise are consistently beneficial.2 A pilot study of midodrine treatment in CFS showed encouraging results; however, these results are preliminary.10 In the patient reported here, midodrine treatment resulted first in correction of dysautonomia as monitored by HIS on tilt test, followed by improvement of fatigue. Suspending midodrine treatment or decreasing the dose was associated with recurrence of dysautonomia and fatigue. These observations may spur larger prospective studies on the principle of manipulating the autonomic nervous system to improve both dysautonomic phenomena and fatigue in CFS. Perforation of duodenal ulcer occurred while our patient was taking midodrine and no other medication, but midodrine was tolerated later. We did not find any reports in the literature of exacerbation of peptic disease during the course of midodrine treatment.
There is need for a placebo controlled trial before midodrine is considered to be a treatment for CFS.
The diagnosis of CFS is based on patient history and exclusion of other medical or psychiatric illnesses.
A particular dysautonomia was revealed in CFS patients on head-up tilt test. The dysautonomic fingerprint of CFS, expressed as “HIS”, may provide objective criteria to the diagnosis.
Review of 350 studies on treatment of CFS showed that only cognitive behaviour therapy and graded exercise were consistently beneficial.
A pilot study of midodrine treatment in CFS showed promising outcomes, resulting in correction of the dysautonomia followed by improvement of fatigue.