Article Text


Pulmonary arteriovenous malformation
  1. I Khurshid,
  2. G H Downie
  1. Department of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine, Brody School of Medicine, East Carolina University, Greenville, North Carolina, USA
  1. Correspondence and reprint requests to:
 Dr Imtiaz Khurshid, Department of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine, Brody School of Medicine, East Carolina University, Greenville, NC 27834, USA;


Pulmonary arteriovenous malformations (PAVM) are rare pulmonary vascular anomalies. Although most patients are asymptomatic, PAVMs can cause dyspnoea from right-to-left shunt. Because of paradoxical emboli, various central nervous system complications have been described including stroke and brain abscess. There is a strong association between PAVM and hereditary haemorrhagic telangiectasia. Chest radiography and contrast enhanced computed tomography are essential initial diagnostic tools but pulmonary angiography is the gold standard. Contrast echocardiography is useful for diagnosis and monitoring after treatment. Most patients should be treated. Therapeutic options include angiographic embolisation with metal coil or balloon occlusion and surgical excision.

  • pulmonary arteriovenous malformation
  • vascular anomaly
  • 3-D, three dimensional
  • HHT, hereditary haemorrhagic telangiectasia
  • PAVA, pulmonary arteriovenous aneurysm
  • PAVM, pulmonary arteriovenous malformation

Statistics from

Direct communications between the branches of pulmonary artery and pulmonary veins, without an intervening pulmonary bed, are probably the most common anomalies of the pulmonary vascular tree and have been variously called a pulmonary arteriovenous fistula, pulmonary arteriovenous malformation (PAVM), pulmonary arteriovenous aneurysm (PAVA), pulmonary angioma, arteriovenous angiomatosis, cavernous haemangiomas, and pulmonary hamartomas.1,2 The lesions usually represent congenital malformation, with the exception of very rare acquired cases, and lack malignant potential; hence the later four terms do not properly represent this entity. Additionally the term PAVA preferentially represents lesions associated with circumscribed dilatation of the pulmonary artery or vein which are visible at angiography or gross inspection. The terms pulmonary arteriovenous fistula and PAVM with arteriovenous shunt can be used interchangeably. PAVM is the preferred term, since it represents a developmental defect.


The first description of PAVM was reported by Churton in 1897.3 He reported the case of a 12 year old boy who had episodes of epistaxis, haemoptysis, and loud pulmonary systolic bruit; at postmortem examination he was found to have multiple bilateral PAVM. In 1917, Wilkins described the necropsy findings in a 23 year old women with cyanosis, clubbing, telangiectasia, and bilateral axillary bruits who died from haemothorax after rupture of a PAVA into the pleural cavity.4 In 1938, Rhodes recognised the association between telangiectasias and PAVAs.5 Smith and Horton in 1939 made the first clinical diagnosis of a PAVM in a 40 year old man who had cyanosis, clubbing, bruit, and polycythaemia.6 In 1942, Hepburn and Dauphinee reported the first case of successful surgical removal of a pulmonary haemangioma with disappearance of the patient's polycythaemia and clubbing after pneumonectomy.7 An alternative to lung parenchymal resection was described by Packard and Waring in 1945, who successfully treated a 31 year old man with a PAVA by ligation of the pulmonary artery.8 Surgical techniques were further refined to lobectomy, instead of pneumonectomy, in 1950 and to local excision in 1959.9,10 Surgery remained the mainstay of treatment until 1978 when Taylor and coworkers reported the first case of successful percutaneous catheterisation and embolisation of a PAVM.11


Since the first reported case in 1897, more than 500 cases have been reported in the literature.1,12–16 The natural history of this rare entity is not completely understood. PAVMs can be either congenital or acquired. More than 80% of PAVMs are congenital, and of these 47%–80% are associated with Osler-Weber-Render disease or hereditary haemorrhagic telangiectasia (HHT).13–16 Conversely, it is estimated that overall, 5%–15% of the population with HHT have a PAVM.13–17 It is clear that stigmata of either of these two entities should alert the clinician to the possibility that both may coexist. In patients with HHT, telangiectases of the skin and oral, nasal, and conjunctival mucosa become apparent in the second and third decades of life. The presence of HHT in a patient with a PAVM may be of prognostic value since the patient with coexisting HHT tends to have worse symptomatology, multiple arteriovenous malformations, rapid disease progression, and a higher complication rate.13–16

The incidence of PAVMs apparently varies according to the specific gene alterations.18,19 The genetic aetiological linkages to HHT are located on chromosome 9 (9q 33–34 or OWR-1) in some families and on chromosome 12 (12q or OWR-2) in others.18,19 The gene for HHT at chromosome 9q3 codes for endoglin, a binding membrane glycoprotein of vascular endothelial cells in arterioles, venules, and capillaries.18 The mutation of endoglin gene can cause vascular dysplasia and is seen more often in patients with genetic linkage to chromosome 9q3.19

Secondary or acquired PAVM, although very rare, has been reported in the literature. Causes of secondary PAVM include chest trauma, thoracic surgery, long standing hepatic cirrhosis, metastatic carcinoma, mitral stenosis, infections (actinomycosis, schistosomiasis), and systemic amyloidosis.12,20–24 Pregnancy has been associated with an increased rate of PAVM growth and its associated complications.25–28 An increased growth rate of a PAVM has been attributed to increased blood volume and cardiac output, which leads to increased pulmonary blood flow, preferentially across the low resistance PAVM.25 The increased blood flow across the PAVM causes its dilatation. Secondly, increased venous distensibility secondary to a progesterone effect causes further augmentation of blood flow and leads to progression in PAVM size. The pregnancy associated increase in steroid hormone synthesis results in an increased incidence of spontaneous haemothorax secondary to intrapleural rupture of PAVM.25,27,28


The incidence of PAVM is 2–3 per 100 000 population.17 The male to female ratio varies from 1:1.5 to 1.8, in several series.13–15 The age at the first presentation ranges from newborn to 70 but the majority of cases are diagnosed in the first three decades of life.1,12–14 PAVMs may be single or multiple in occurrence and the incidence of single PAVMs ranges from 42% to 74%.10,13,14,29 Most solitary PAVMs are seen in bilateral lower lobes, the left lower lobe being the most common location, followed by right lower lobe, left upper lobe, right middle lobe, and right upper lobe.10,14,29 The majority of multiple PAVMs are also confined to bilateral lower lobes; the incidence of bilateral PAVMs ranges from 8% to 20%.10,12

All PAVMs have an afferent supply, usually from one or more branches of the pulmonary artery. However afferent supply sometimes, in part or all, is derived from the systemic circulation; the source of systemic supply includes the aorta, intercostal and bronchial arteries.10,12 The efferent limb of an arteriovenous malformation drains into one or more branches of the pulmonary vein; sometimes abnormal efferent vessels may drain directly into the left atrium or inferior vena cava, instead of the pulmonary vein.30 PAVMs are usually found in close proximity to the visceral pleura or embedded in the outer third of lung parenchyma. In a study of 110 patients with a single PAVM, 89 (81%) of the lesions were either subpleural or partially embedded in the lung parenchyma.10

The classification of PAVMs, including embryology and anatomic variations, has been reviewed by Anabtawi and colleagues.30 They have classified PAVMs in five groups (box 1), and this classification is based on embryological development of the lung and pulmonary vasculature. They suggest that the separate embryonic development of the pulmonary arterial, capillary, and venous systems allows anomalies of the pulmonary circulation in these systems, either in combination or as an isolated lesion. Additionally isolated abnormal development of capillaries can result in arteriovenous shunting with no visible malformation. Cooley and McNamara were the first to describe a case of microscopic PAVM, diagnosed by open lung biopsy in a cyanotic patient with normal chest radiographs and pulmonary angiogram.31 The most commonly encountered vascular anomaly is a primitive venous plexus with persistence of large vascular channels of aneurysmal proportions, which we recognise as PAVM.

Box 1: Anatomical classification of PAVMs (derived from Anatwabi et al30)

Group I

  • Multiple small arteriovenous fistulas.

  • Without aneurysm.

Group II

  • Large arteriovenous aneurysm.

Group III

  • Large arteriovenous aneurysm (central).

  • Large arteriovenous aneurysm with anomalous venous drainage.

  • Multiple small arteriovenous fistulas with anomalous venous drainage.

  • Group IV

  • Large venous aneurysm with systemic artery communication.

  • Large venous aneurysm without fistula.

  • Group V

    • Anomalous venous drainage with fistulas.


    In contrast to systemic arteriovenous malformation, PAVMs do not affect cardiac haemodynamics.12,13,16 Cardiac output, cardiac index, pulmonary capillary wedge pressure, heart rate, blood pressure, and the electrocardiogram are usually within normal limits. The fundamental defect is right-to-left shunt from the pulmonary artery to the pulmonary vein, the degree of shunt is what determines the clinical effects on the patient.12,16 If shunting is minimal, the symptoms are usually subacute or even absent. If the right-to-left shunt is greater than 20% of the systemic cardiac output or there is reduction of haemoglobin more than 50 g/l, the patient will have obvious cyanosis, clubbing, and polycythaemia. In some cases of HHT, cyanosis may be hidden by anaemia caused by epistaxis or gastrointestinal blood. The red cell mass and blood volume are usually increased while the plasma volume is normal.6,12 The peripheral oxygen saturation is low and as expected does not normalise with 100% oxygen.


    An accurate analysis of the clinical findings seen in PAVM is difficult because many of the published series overlap disease entities; therefore recorded data specific for PAVM are not uniform and often are incomplete. Asymptomatic patients are common and account for between 13% to 55% of patients in different series.13–15,25 So absence of symptoms does not preclude the diagnosis of PAVM. The most common presenting symptom is dyspnoea on exertion, which is seen in 31% to 67% of patients (box 2).1,13–17 The severity of dyspnoea is related to the degree of hypoxaemia and the magnitude of the shunt. The majority of the patients with PAVMs tolerate hypoxaemia very well and are relatively or completely asymptomatic unless the arterial oxygen pressure is less than 8.0 kPa (60 mm Hg). Epistaxis, melaena, and neurological symptoms should alert the clinician to the possibility of coexisting HHT. Epistaxis is relatively more common in patients with HHT.14,15,17 In a sizeable number of patients (43%–67%), a history of neurological symptoms—that is, headache, vertigo, paresis, numbness, paresthaesia, syncope, or confusion—can be found.15,17 In one study, the classic triad of dyspnoea, cyanosis, and clubbing was found in only 10% of patients with a PAVM.32

    Box 2: Clinical features of PAVMs


    • Dyspnoea.

    • Epistaxis.

    • Haemoptysis.

    • Palpitation.

    • Chest pain.

    • Cough.


    • Bruit/thrill.

    • Clubbing.

    • Cyanosis.

    • Telangiectasia.

    • Polycythaemia.

    • Anaemia.


    • Hypoxaemia.

    • Intrabronchial rupture, haemoptysis.

    • Intrapleural rupture, haemothorax.

    • Paradoxical embolisation.

    • Polycythaemia.

    • Pulmonary hypertension.

    • Endocarditis.

    • Transient ischaemic attack.

    • Cerebrovascular accident.

    • Migraine headache.

    • Brain abscess.

    • Congestive heart failure.

    A meticulous physical examination will detect abnormal physical findings in up to 75% of patients.32 The most common physical findings are cyanosis, clubbing, and pulmonary vascular bruit (box 2).1,13,15 Classically, the pulmonary bruit is increased by inspiration and the Muller manoeuvre (forced inspiration with a closed glottis after full expiration), this is caused by an increase in the pulmonary blood flow and decreased by expiration and the Valsalva manoeuvre, by decreasing venous return to the lung. Mucocutaneous telangiectasias have been reported in up to two thirds of HHT patients with a PAVM.15,17 Massive haemoptysis after intrabronchial rupture of a lesion or haemothorax after rupture of a subpleural lesion is rare but potentially a fatal complication of PAVM.25,27 The presence of symptoms usually correlates with the size of lesion, a single PAVM less than 2 cm in diameter on chest radiography usually does not cause symptoms.13,14

    The most commonly reported complications relate to the central nervous system and the incidence varies in different series from 19% to 59%.15,17,25,33 In one study the reported incidence of different neurological events was as follows: migraine 43%, transient ischaemic attack 37%, stroke 18%, abscess 9%, and seizure 8%.33 The most likely mechanism for these neurological events is paradoxical embolism across the PAVM or across a coexisting cerebral arteriovenous malformation in patients with HHT. Less common but life threatening complications include haemoptysis and haemothorax. Haemoptysis may be due to intrabronchial rupture of PAVM or endobronchial telangiectasis, while haemothorax may result from rupture of a subpleural PAVM. In a study of 143 patients with PAVM, who were referred for embolotherapy, 11 (8%) had a history of massive haemoptysis or haemothorax.27 Pulmonary haemorrhage was the presenting symptom in nine of the 11 patients, seven of the 11 patients were female, three of whom experienced symptoms during pregnancy.27


    Chest radiography is an important diagnostic tool not only in diagnosis but also in the follow up of patients with a PAVM. A plain chest radiograph shows abnormalities in about 98% of patients.13–15 The classic radiographic features of PAVM are a round or oval sharply defined mass of uniform density, frequently lobulated, and ranging in size from 1–5 cm in diameter; two thirds are located in the lower lobes (figs 1 and 2).10,12,13 A plain chest radiograph may show a connecting vessel radiating from the hilum.13,14 Chest tomography, although not used commonly, is more accurate in identifying connecting vessels and PAVM.13

    Figure 1

    Posteroanterior chest radiograph showing a large, single PAVM in right lower hemithorax.

    Figure 2

    Lateral chest radiograph showing a large, single PAVM in right lower hemithorax.

    The shunt fraction, the fraction of cardiac output that shunts from right-to-left through a PAVM, is raised in 88% to 100% of selected patients with a PAVM.13–15,34 Shunt fraction is most accurately measured by the 100% oxygen method, which involves measurements of oxygen saturation and arterial oxygen pressure after breathing 100% oxygen for 15 to 20 minutes. A shunt fraction of equal to or greater than 5% by this method is considered abnormal. In a study of 32 patients, the shunt fraction ranged from 3.5% to 35% and a higher shunt fraction was observed in patients with multiple PAVM.34

    Contrast echocardiography involves injection of agitated saline or dye into a peripheral vein; it is extremely sensitive in detecting left-to-right shunt but it does not provide quantitative or anatomic detail of the shunt. In patients without right-to-left shunt, an air bubble or dye may rapidly appear in the right atrium and then gradually dissipate as the bubbles become trapped in the pulmonary circulation.12 In the case of intracardiac shunt, bubbles will be visualised in the left atrium within one cardiac cycle after their appearance in the right atrium.35 In contrast, a PAVM will demonstrate a delay of three to eight cardiac cycles before the bubbles will be visualised in the left atrium.35 On occasion, if bubbles or contrast can be seen entering the left atrium through a single pulmonary vein, it confirms the ipsilateral anatomical localisation of the PAVM. In addition, contrast echocardiography allows assessment of efficiency of embolotherapy and is useful to exclude the presence of PAVM in family members of patients with HHT.36

    Radionuclide perfusion lung scan is a useful adjunct in the diagnosis and quantification of PAVM.36 However, as with contrast echocardiography, a positive result is not specific for PAVM, whereas a negative result essentially excludes the diagnosis. Radionuclide scanning also allows the quantification of shunt magnitude, the results of which are comparable to the 100% oxygen shunt calculation method.36 Like contrast echocardiography, radionuclide perfusion lung scanning does not provide information about anatomical detail of the PAVM. Despite a high negative predictive value, radionuclide perfusion lung scanning is not employed routinely.

    Contrast enhanced computed tomography is a valuable tool in diagnosis and defining the vascular anatomy of PAVM (fig 3).37 Remy et al compared the usefulness of contrast enhanced computed tomography with selective pulmonary angiography and found that computed tomography scanning was significantly better than conventional angiography in detecting a PAVM (98 v 60%).37 However, angiography was better able to determine the angioarchitecture of individual PAVMs than computed tomography. The superiority of computed tomography scanning in detecting PAVM is attributed to the absence of superimposition of lesions in transaxial computed tomography views. Three dimensional (3-D) helical computed tomography, a relatively new technique that is not widely available, is also being used for the diagnosis of pulmonary vascular lesions. In a comparative study, 3-D helical computed tomography allowed full analysis of 76% of PAVM, compared with only 32% by conventional unilateral pulmonary angiography.37 The use of 3-D helical computed tomography is limited by time, prolonged breath holding, and the inability to visualise large PAVMs.38 Additionally there have been case reports of the false positive diagnosis of PAVMs by computed tomography.39 So a contrast enhanced computed tomography scan is a useful and widely available diagnostic tool in patients with abnormal chest radiography suspicious of PAVM and also to rule out any coexisting process.

    Figure 3

    Computed tomogram section demonstrates a well circumscribed density in right lower lobe connected by a blood vessel.

    The use of magnetic resonance imaging to diagnose PAVM has been limited compared with that of computed tomography.40,41 Most lesions within the lung have a relatively long relaxation time and produce medium to high intensity signals. In contrast, PAVMs and aneurysms with rapid blood flow in the lesion result in a signal void and produce low intensity signals.42 Additional low signal intensity lesions include air cyst, calcified lesion, fibrous scar, cystic lesion, and haematoma. These lesions make it hard to differentiate PAVMs from these lesions with the standard magnetic resonance imaging technique, so application of additional techniques have been suggested to visualise pulmonary vascular lesions.40,41 There are isolated case reports of successful diagnosis of PAVM by magnetic resonance angiography obviating the need for pulmonary angiography.42 The main reasons limiting the use of magnetic resonance angiography for routine use are limited availability, relative expense, and the need for highly specialised staff to interpret the data.

    In spite of all the advances in the techniques mentioned thus far, pulmonary angiography remains the gold standard in the diagnosis of PAVM (fig 4).1,12,14,16 Pulmonary angiography is justified to confirm the diagnosis in virtually all cases. A pulmonary angiogram not only identifies the PAVM but also further defines the angioarchitecture of pulmonary vasculature, which is necessary before therapeutic embolisation or surgical resection. Angiography should be performed on all portions of the lung to look for any unsuspected PAVM and source of intrathoracic or extrathoracic vascular communications. Computed tomography and magnetic resonance angiography, for the diagnosis of PAVM, should be reserved for those patients who cannot undergo angiography or for the follow up of patients with a proved PAVM.

    Figure 4

    Angiogram showing large, single PAVM of right lower lobe with a single artery.

    In some patients with a normal chest radiograph, the presence of hypoxaemia signifies the existence of a small PAVM causing shunt. Contrast enhanced computed tomography may show multiple small PAVMs, which sometimes are not visible on pulmonary angiography because of their angiographically small size. The clinical significance of these small PAVMs is not clear at present.

    At our institution, contrast enhanced computed tomography is done once a chest radiograph abnormality suspicious of PAVM is found. Contrast echocardiography is done to determine the presence of right-to-left shunt and shunt fraction is determined by the 100% oxygen method. Finally, if the patient is eligible for further intervention, pulmonary angiography is done to define anatomical details of the lesion.


    Although the first successful surgical resection of a PAVM was reported in 1942,7 a consensus opinion of PAVM management has not been reached; one reason is the uncertainty of the natural history of PAVM. There is not a single prospective study of patients who were randomised to treatment versus observation only. There is evidence that PAVMs progressively enlarge over a period of time and incidence of progression is higher in patients with untreated PAVM.1,13,15,32 The morbidity associated with PAVM was up to 50% in untreated patients compared with 3% in patients who received treatment.13,15,32 There has been considerable overlap of cases in earlier studies, which makes it difficult to estimate the mortality.1,13–17 The mortality figure ranges from 0% to 55% in these studies.1,13,15,32 In spite of limited information about the natural history of PAVM, available data suggest treatment should be offered to all symptomatic patients and asymptomatic patients with lesions less than 2 cm in diameter on chest radiography.14 The purpose of treatment includes prevention of neurological complications, progressive hypoxia and its resultant effects, and high output cardiac failure.

    Since the first successful resection of PAVM in 1942, surgery was the only treatment available until 1978, when Taylor et al reported the first successful percutaneous embolisation.7,11 The current preferred treatment for the majority of patients with a PAVM is percutaneous embolotherapy using coils or balloons; this method has largely replaced surgical intervention.33,34,43–45 Embolotherapy, being less invasive and easy to repeat, has definite advantages over surgery. Two methods have been used for embolisation—that is, balloons and metallic coils. Each method has its advantages, disadvantages, and complications.33,34,43,44 Both techniques involve localisation of the PAVM by angiography followed by selective catheterisation of the feeding artery.33,43 In coil embolisation, the catheter tip is positioned as close to the neck of PAVM as possible, a steel coil is advanced through the catheter and released at this point.43 Angiography is then repeated to ensure the position of the coil and to make certain the cessation of blood flow across the PAVM (figs 5 and 6). In balloon embolisation, after localisation of the PAVM by angiography, a balloon catheter is exchanged over guidewire and positioned at the neck of the feeding vessel.33 The balloon is inflated and angiography is repeated to ensure vessel occlusion. If there is no flow across the PAVM, the balloon is detached.

    Figure 5

    Chest radiograph showing complete occlusion of PAVM after coil embolisation.

    Figure 6

    Angiogram showing nest of coils producing complete occlusion of PAVM.

    Embolisation results are shown in table 1; a total of 808 PAVMs were occluded in 288 patients. Coil embolisation was used slightly more frequently than balloon embolisation. The overall success rate was over 99% (808 attempts for 803 PAVM occluded). There was no reported mortality in these series.33,34,43–45 The most commonly encountered complication was self limiting pleuritic chest pain, which was seen in up to 13% of patients.33,43,46 The incidence of pleuritic chest pain was higher (31%) in patients with larger PAVMs (feeding vessel >8 mm).44 Pulmonary infarction was radiographically observed in 3% of patients.33,45 Air embolism during embolisation is rare, but can cause transient symptoms such as angina, bradycardia, and perioral paresthaesias.33 Other reported complications include device migration, myocardial rupture, cerebrovascular accident, vascular injury, early deflation of balloon, deep vein thrombosis, and pulmonary hypertension.33,46,47 In summary, contemporary embolisation techniques with minimal morbidity and no mortality, renders radiological intervention as the first line of treatment for PAVM. Embolotherapy is a suitable alternative to surgical intervention in the elderly who are poor surgical candidates, in patients with multiple lesions, and patients who decline surgery. At our institution all patients with PAVM are evaluated by an interventional radiologist for embolotherapy before being considered for surgery.

    Table 1

    Outcome of patients undergoing embolisation for PAVM

    Surgical resection of PAVMs is indicated in patients who fail embolotherapy, develop serious bleeding complication despite embolotherapy, have intrapleural rupture of the PAVM, or have untreatable contrast allergy and lesions not amenable to embolotherapy. Different surgical techniques have been employed which include local excision, segmental resection, lobectomy, ligation, and even pneumonectomy. Lung conserving resection, local resection, or segmentectomy is the procedure of choice whenever possible. Staged bilateral thoracotomies were performed in a case of an extensive bilateral PAVM.48 Recently video assisted thoracoscopy has been employed in the resection of a small PAVM.49 PAVM surgery has the same risk as any other thoracic surgery procedure, but when properly performed in well selected patients, it results in minimal morbidity and mortality.10,13,15 The reported mortality in a case series published after 1960 is zero.13–15,34 In summary, surgical resection of a PAVM is an acceptable option in those patients who are not amenable to embolotherapy. It is associated with minimal mortality and morbidity and requires a hospital stay.

    Mortality and morbidity in untreated PAVMs is shown in table 2.

    Table 2

    Mortality and morbidity in untreated PAVMs


    PAVMs are an uncommon clinical problem. The classic triad of dyspnoea on exertion, cyanosis, and clubbing should alert the clinician to the possibility of a PAVM. There is a strong association between PAVM and HHT. All patients with PAVMs should be screened for cerebral arteriovenous malformation by contrast enhanced head computed tomography or magnetic resonance imaging. The chest radiograph often suggests the diagnosis of PAVM and contrast enhanced computed tomography or pulmonary angiography is usually diagnostic. Contrast echocardiography confirms the presence of right-to-left shunt and shunt fraction can be measured by the 100% oxygen method or by radionuclide perfusion lung scanning. Pulmonary angiography is necessary before embolotherapy or surgical intervention, to document number and location of all lesions. A simplified approach to diagnose and/or to follow up a PAVM is presented in fig 7. Embolotherapy, where available, is a relatively safe and effective procedure and the preferred treatment for PAVMs. Lung conserving resection is the optimal option for symptomatic patients where embolotherapy was unsuccessful or technically not feasible. The risk of serial growth of occult lesions and recanalisation of previously embolised PAVM dictates that patients should have a regular follow up.

    Figure 7

    An approach in patients suspected of having a PAVM or to follow up patients with PAVM.


    View Abstract

    Request permissions

    If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.