Alcohol is a major cause of liver cirrhosis in the Western world and accounts for the majority of cases of liver cirrhosis seen in district general hospitals in the UK. The three most widely recognised forms of alcoholic liver disease are alcoholic fatty liver (steatosis), acute alcoholic hepatitis, and alcoholic cirrhosis. The exact pathogenesis of alcoholic liver injury is still not clear but immune mediated and free radical hepatic injury are thought to be important. There is increasing interest in genetic factors predisposing to hepatic injury in susceptible individuals. Diagnosis is based on accurate history, raised serum markers such as γ-glutamyltransferase, mean corpuscular volume, and IgA and liver histology when obtainable. Abstinence is the most important aspect of treatment. Newer drugs such as acamprosate and naltrexone are used to reduce alcohol craving. Vitamin supplements and nutrition are vital while corticosteroids have a role in acute alcoholic hepatitis where there is no evidence of gastrointestinal haemorrhage or sepsis. Liver transplantation has excellent results in abstinent patients with end stage liver disease but there are concerns about recidivism after transplant.
- liver disease
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Alcoholic liver disease (ALD) is one of the major medical complications of alcohol abuse. Alcohol is the major cause of liver cirrhosis in the Western world, with schistosomial infection being the major cause of portal hypertension in the developing countries. Alcohol accounts for 80% of all liver cirrhosis cases seen in district general hospitals in the UK. Alcoholic cirrhosis is increasingly seen in countries such as Japan and India which traditionally had a low prevalence of the disease.
The safe limits for alcohol intake are controversial. Guidelines recommended by the Royal College of Physicians advise a weekly limit of 21 units (210 g) of alcohol in men and 14 units in women. The 1994 Office of Population Censuses and Surveys' General Household Survey found that 27% of men and 13% of women in the UK were exceeding these limits. A recent prospective Italian study in 6534 subjects showed the risk threshold for developing ALD is 30 g ethanol/day and this risk increases with increasing daily intake.1 Women had greater susceptibility to ALD in the range of 3–8 drinks daily. A previous study in 13 285 Danish subjects found that ALD was increased above a threshold of 7–13 drinks per week in females and 14–27 drinks in males.2 There was a steep dose dependent increase in ALD risk above this threshold with increasing alcohol intake. Women had greater susceptibility to ALD at any given level of intake. Kwoet al have recently shown that men and women have equivalent alcohol elimination rates.3 The gender differences in susceptibility to liver injury may be due to pharmacokinetic reasons such as differences in ethanol absorption or alternatively differences in the response of the liver to alcohol induced injury such as that caused by oxidative by-products of ethanol metabolism in the liver.
Box 1: Safe limits for alcohol intake
Males = 21 units per week (1 unit = glass or half pint)
Females = 14 units per week
Box 2: Factors increasing susceptibility to ALD
Lifetime intake of alcohol
Drinking without food
High concentration alcoholic drinks—for example, spirits
Drinking multiple different alcoholic beverages
The pattern of drinking was also important as ALD is increased in those who drink without accompanying food and also in those who drink multiple different alcoholic beverages.1 It is well known that food delays gastric emptying and intestinal absorption of alcohol and thus intake of food before drinking will decrease the rise of blood alcohol concentrations. The absorption of alcohol is lower when consuming low concentration beverages such as beer compared with high concentration spirits.
A recent study in 12 687 subjects showed that coffee consumption protected males from the induction of γ-glutamyltransferase by alcohol and may possibly protect against liver cell damage caused by alcohol.4
Spectrum of liver disease
The three most widely recognised forms of ALD are alcoholic fatty liver (steatosis), acute alcoholic hepatitis, and alcoholic cirrhosis. At least 80% of heavy drinkers develop steatosis, 10%–35% develop alcoholic hepatitis, and approximately 10% will develop cirrhosis.5
ALCOHOLIC FATTY LIVER (STEATOSIS)
Steatosis is invariable if consumption exceeds 80 g of alcohol per day. A large proportion of the cytoplasm of affected hepatocytes is occupied by a single large triglyceride occlusion but liver function is often normal. It is reversible with abstinence but may progress to cirrhosis if excess alcohol intake persists.6 Deaths due directly to fatty liver are rare and are usually caused by acute liver failure or fat embolism.
ACUTE ALCOHOLIC HEPATITIS
In alcoholic hepatitis, hepatocyte ballooning occurs due to increased intracellular water accumulation. Mallory's hyaline bodies are perinuclear eosinophilic inclusion bodies and are probably condensed and disorganised fragments of the cytoskeletal framework of the hepatocyte. They are not specific for alcoholic hepatitis as they are also seen in Wilson's disease and primary biliary cirrhosis. It has been estimated that 15–20 years of excessive drinking is necessary to develop alcoholic hepatitis. There is prominent cholestasis. It is more severe in females and also in Northern Europeans and is unrelated to pattern of drinking or type of alcohol drink. High mortality rates are seen (30%–60%). Patients often deteriorate after hospital admission despite abstinence. This latter phenomenon may be due to reperfusion liver injury.
Cirrhosis is the most severe form of alcoholic liver injury and is usually of the micronodular type. The risk is increased in continuous drinkers compared to binge drinkers. Collagen deposition can be pericellular, in the space of Disse, and around central veins (central hyaline sclerosis). The latter is often associated with rapid progression to cirrhosis and commoner and more severe in women. Collagen bridges eventually develop between central veins and portal tracts isolating groups of hepatocytes which form the regeneration nodules. Survival for patients is 60%–70% at one year and 35%–50% at five years.
There are a number of hypotheses regarding the pathogenesis of alcoholic liver injury.
Ethanol metabolism usually takes place in the mitochondria. Ethanol is oxidised to acetaldehyde by alcohol dehydrogenase, which in turn is oxidised to acetate by acetaldehyde dehydrogenase. These oxidation reactions are associated with the formation of NADH and NAD and alter the redox state of the cell. This has harmful effects on lipid and carbohydrate metabolism—for example, steatosis. In habitual drinkers, a microsomal mixed function oxidase, the microsomal ethanol oxidising system, is increased by enzyme induction and is also responsible for production of acetaldehyde.
Acetaldehyde is increased in zone 3 (also the maximal site of action of alcohol dehydrogenase). This is also the site of the terminal veins making this zone the most hypoxic and therefore highly susceptible to hypoxic injury. Oxygen derived free radicals may cause direct hepatocyte injury by lipid peroxidation.
Box 3: Major classification of ALD
Alcoholic fatty liver (steatosis)
Acute alcoholic hepatitis
Box 4: Histological features of ALD
Steatosis (fatty liver)
Mallory's hyaline bodies
Soluble fatty acid synthase (FAS) and FAS ligand are increased in patients with acute alcoholic hepatitis and alcoholic cirrhosis while they are normal in chronic hepatitis C.13 These soluble mediators could be produced in hepatocytes, Kuppfer cells, or polymorphonuclear cells in the liver. Their exact role in alcoholic liver injury needs to be determined.
Twin studies suggest a genetic component to disease susceptibility.14 In white people, associations between ALD risk and polymorphisms of the genes encoding the cytochromeP-450 CYP2E115 and TNF-α16 have been shown. The frequency of an alcohol dehydrogenase 3 allele has been found to differ in alcohol related liver disease and controls.17 IL-10 polymorphism is associated with an increased risk (× 1.8) of ALD.
Hepatitis C viraemia and alcohol have an additive effect on the risk of liver injury.18 Alcohol may impair the immune system's response to the virus or increased hepatic iron secondary to alcohol may modify the clinical course of hepatitis C virus.
There is significant iron deposition in alcoholic livers.19 A recent study found no link between simple heterozygotes of either HFE gene and risk of ALD.20Comparing 257 patients with ALD and 117 healthy controls, 15.7 % of fibrotic/cirrhotic patients were C282Y heterozygote compared with 13.7% of controls. Of chromosomes without the C282Y mutation, 15.4% of ALD and 16.6% of controls were H63D heterozygote. Significant iron staining was found in 6/23 C282Y heterozygotes versus 4/26 H63D heterozygotes versus 4/23 controls. Simple heterozygotes are not more susceptible to developing iron catalysed oxidative stress during ethanol consumption. Patients with ALD have increased iron accumulation, independent of HFE genotype. This may be because of folic acid deficiency increasing iron absorption.21 Oxidative stress increases the activity of iron regulatory proteins which bind to iron response elements in the messenger RNAs of iron regulating genes such as the transferrin receptor and ferritin.22 This results in an increase in free iron in the hepatocyte. Hepatic siderosis in an alcoholic may identify those most susceptible to oxidative stress—because of genetic or environmental reasons. There is an inverse correlation between liver iron staining and survival in alcoholic cirrhosis.23
Alcohol increases portal blood flow and also hepatic vascular resistance leading to an increase in portal pressure and collateral blood flow.24 This increases the risk of variceal bleeding in patients with alcoholic cirrhosis and portal hypertension.
Alcohol can cause significant liver damage without producing any symptoms or signs of liver disease. Many people are diagnosed when they have routine liver function tests as part of a medical check-up. Patients may present with non-specific features such as nausea, vomiting, abdominal discomfort, or diarrhoea. Patients with advanced liver disease may present with jaundice, ascites, encephalopathy, or upper gastrointestinal bleeding.
ALD may be detected when patients present voluntarily for detoxification. Patients may present with other sequelae of alcoholism such as pneumonia, rib fractures, or head injury. Liver damage may be detected when patients present with alcoholic damage to other organs such as the pancreas, heart, brain, and peripheral nerves.
Patients with fatty liver usually look well and often have only mild hepatomegaly with no other stigmata of chronic liver disease.
Box 5: Putative pathogenic mechanisms
Reduced antioxidant defences
Box 6: Clinical features
Upper gastrointestinal bleeding
In alcoholic hepatitis patients usually look very unwell, are malnourished, and often pyrexial. Patients are often deeply jaundiced and cutaneous features of chronic liver disease are common. There is often marked hepatomegaly which is tender on palpation. Hepatic bruits may be heard. Splenomegaly is uncommon. Ascites and hepatic encephalopathy are common but varices are not common. Upper gastrointestinal bleeding does occur but is usually due to gastric erosions or peptic ulceration on a background of coagulopathy. Infections are very common during the illness.
The clinical features of alcoholic cirrhosis are similar to non-alcoholic cirrhosis. It is thought that spider telangiectasia, parotid enlargement, gynaecomastia, and hepatomegaly are more common in alcoholic cirrhosis.
The most important part of the diagnostic work-up is obtaining a reliable history of prolonged alcohol abuse. Patients are often not forthcoming until they gain the trust of their doctor and so their general practitioner may be in the best position to make the diagnosis. Various questionnaires such as the CAGE test are useful in screening for alcohol abuse. A collateral history from spouses, family members, and friends is very important.
The two commonest laboratory indices in detecting excessive alcohol consumption are a raised serum γ-glutamyltransferase and mean corpuscular volume. Individually these test have a sensitivity of 30%–40% but combining the tests is much more informative. A moderately raised γ-glutamyltransferase can be found in non-alcoholic fatty liver and also in patients taking drugs which induce hepatic enzymes such as phenytoin. An isolated raised γ-glutamyltransferase in a heavy drinker with otherwise normal liver function tests is usually associated with only mild histological liver damage which is reversible. Many clinicians therefore feel a liver biopsy to assess liver injury is unnecessary in this situation.
Serum carbohydrate deficient transferrin is a specific and sensitive test of alcoholism but is not widely available and many feel that a combination of γ-glutamyltransferase and mean corpuscular volume is just as useful.
Serum transaminase levels are often not greatly raised in ALD and values greater than five times the upper limit of the normal reference range should lead to consideration of other diagnoses such as viral or autoimmune hepatitis. Hyperbilirubinaemia reflects the severity of the hepatitis and is greatly increased in alcoholic hepatitis.
Prolongation of the prothrombin time and hypoalbuminaemia reflect poor hepatic synthetic function.
A score based on prothrombin time (seconds) and serum bilirubin (mmol/l) is used to determine short term prognosis in alcoholic hepatitis.25 The discriminant function (DF) is calculated from the equation DF = 4.6 (prothrombin time − control time) + serum bilirubin/17.1. A score >32 denotes severe disease with a two month mortality of 50% and these patients should be given a trial of corticosteroids.
Leucocytosis is common in alcoholic hepatitis as is thrombocytopenia, which occurs secondary to direct alcohol toxicity or to hypersplenism found in portal hypertension. Electrolyte abnormalities commonly found are hyponatraemia and hypokalaemia and less commonly hypocalcaemia and hypomagnesaemia.
Ultrasound scanning can reveal the presence of fatty liver and hepatitis through changes in the reflectivity of the liver parenchyma. An irregular shrunken liver suggests severe cirrhosis while additional pointers to liver disease such as ascites, varices, and splenomegaly can be identified. Doppler studies can demonstrate changes in hepatic artery and portal vein flow. Newer radiological tools such as magnetic resonance spectroscopy are being evaluated.26
A number of serum markers of fibrosis have been shown to reflect severity of alcoholic liver injury such as procollagen III propeptide, laminin, and type IV collagen. However they lack enough sensitivity and specificity to be used in individual cases.
Liver biopsy is necessary to confirm the extent of liver injury and to provide a prognostic guide. The coagulopathy accompanying alcoholic hepatitis and cirrhosis makes this a riskier procedure, which may necessitate using the transjugular venous route for performing the biopsy.
Box 7: CAGE questionnaire
C. Have you ever felt the need to cut down your drinking?
A. Have you ever felt annoyed by criticism of your drinking?
G. Have you ever felt guilty about your drinking?
E. Have you ever taken a drink (eye opener) first thing in the morning?
Score 1 for each positive response. A score of 2 or more suggests alcohol excess.
Box 8: Investigations
Mean corpuscular volume
Carbohydrate deficient transferrin
Bilirubin (markedly raised in acute alcoholic hepatitis)
Serum transaminases: if greater than five times normal suspect other liver pathology
Serum fibrosis markers: procollagen III propeptide, laminin, type IV collagen
Liver ultrasound: also detect splenomegaly and ascites
Portal pressure measurements taken at hepatic venography may be superior to the Child-Pugh score in predicting mortality and bleeding risk in patients with alcoholic cirrhosis but no previous bleeding.27
The most important aspect of treatment is abstinence from alcohol. This should be encouraged with help from the patient's family and friends, psychiatric intervention, and also support groups such as Alcoholics Anonymous. Despite these measures, many patients continue to abuse alcohol and this has led to great interest in pharmacological agents to treat alcohol dependence. The opiate antagonist, naltrexone has been licensed in the USA for treatment of alcoholism since 1994. This is used in patients who are actively drinking, where it has been shown to reduce craving and the level of drinking over several months. It has no role in enhancing abstinence. A newer opiate antagonist, nalmefene, has the advantage of not being toxic to the liver and having no first-pass metabolism but data are insufficient at present to recommend its clinical use. Acamprosate is the other agent which has also been shown to reduce drink frequency but its effect on abstinence is unclear. The mode of action of acamprosate is unknown but it appears to interact with glutamate receptors and calcium channels. A recent meta-analysis has confirmed the clinical benefits of naltrexone and acamprosate but has cast doubt on the benefits of disulfiram which has been traditionally used to promote abstinence.28 The meta-analysis also showed that serotonergic drugs and lithium have no clinical benefit in managing alcohol misuse.
Vitamin B deficiency is common in ALD, in particular thiamine, folate, pyridoxine, and riboflavine. Parenteral vitamin B supplementation is preferred due to lower absorption of oral preparations in alcoholism and malnutrition. Wernicke's encephalopathy has occurred despite high dose vitamin B supplementation orally.29 Concerns exist regarding use of parenteral vitamin B preparation after the publication in 1989 by the Committee on Safety of Medicines of a warning about serious adverse reactions relating to Parenterovite. Parenterovite was later withdrawn world wide in 1992 due to manufacturing problems. A new intravenous preparation, Pabrinex, was introduced in 1993. In reality, Parenterovite caused a serious reaction in only one in 250 000 cases in the UK and no serious reactions were described in 300 000 patients treated with intravenous thiamine in the USA.30 These figures pale in comparison with reported allergic reactions in 1%–10% of penicillin administrations and 1%–18% of streptokinase administrations. We routinely administer Pabrinex I and II ampoules diluted in 50–100 ml 5% dextrose given over 30 minutes. This is given twice daily for three days and then patients are switched to oral thiamine 300 mg daily and multivitamins (two daily). One important consideration is that thiamine should be administered before a glucose load in alcoholics with hypoglycaemia as the glucose load may deplete already borderline thiamine stores and thus precipitate Wernicke's encephalopathy.
Patients should be assessed by a dietitian and receive nutritional supplements while very malnourished patients may benefit from nasogastric or nasojejunal feeding.
Patients often require a reducing dose of chlormethiazole or chlordiazepoxide to prevent alcohol withdrawal phenomena. Intravenous chlormethiazole is occasionally used in very agitated patients but should only be used where close cardiorespiratory monitoring is available.
As with other types of liver disease, therapy is indicated for the complications such as hypoglycaemia, ascites, encephalopathy, variceal bleeding, infection, coagulopathy, and renal impairment. When considering encephalopathy in an alcoholic patient, it is important to differentiate this from subdural haematomata, delirium tremens, and Wernicke's encephalopathy.
There is great debate regarding the benefits of corticosteroids in acute alcoholic hepatitis. They inhibit immune mechanisms that cause liver damage as a result of the formation of antibodies to acetaldehyde products. Two meta-analyses suggest that corticosteroids are beneficial in improving short term survival in patients with severe alcoholic hepatitis.31 32 This was confirmed in a randomised, double blind trial comparing 28 days of prednisolone 40 mg daily with placebo in 61 patients with alcoholic hepatitis. At 66 days, mortality in the placebo group was 84% compared with 12.5% in the prednisolone treated group.33 Corticosteroids should not be given if patients have gastrointestinal bleeding, active infection, pancreatitis, or decompensated diabetes. Otherwise, if patients have severe alcoholic hepatitis in terms of encephalopathy, coagulopathy, leucocytosis, hyperbilirubinaemia or ascites, we treat them with prednisolone 40 mg daily for 28 days. We often judge the severity clinically rather than adhering rigidly to Maddrey's discriminant function score as mentioned previously. Even if short term mortality is reduced, the long term benefits on mortality and prevention of progression to cirrhosis are still unknown.
Propylthiouracil has been proposed as a treatment for ALD because it abolishes the ethanol induced increase in liver oxygen consumption that follows long term ethanol administration.34 Initial trials in alcoholic hepatitis produced conflicting results.35 36However, a study in 310 patients with chronic liver disease showed that those receiving propylthiouracil (300 mg daily) had a 50% reduced mortality rate compared with placebo.37 Further studies are awaited to confirm these data and therefore the drug is not routinely used in a clinical setting at present.
Box 9: Management
Abstinence: support groups, opiate antagonists, acamprosate
Vitamins: thiamine, folic acid, and other B vitamins
Nutrition supplements: nasogastric feeding in malnourished
Corticosteroids for severe acute alcoholic hepatitis
Standard treatment for decompensation features such as hypoglycaemia, ascites, varices, infections, encephalopathy, renal failure, and coagulopathy
Box 10: Research treatments
Saturated fatty acids
Soya bean lecithin
Monoclonal anti-TNF antibodies
S-adenosyl-l-methionine dietary supplement therapy has been used in ALD as it replenishes liver mitochondrial glutathione levels.40 41 A defect in transporting glutathione from cytosol into mitochondria caused by ethanol depletes the mitochondrial pool of glutathione. This renders ethanol fed hepatocytes more susceptible to the cytotoxic effects of inflammatory cytokines such as TNF-α by amplifying the generation of reactive oxygen species within mitochondria.
Saturated fatty acids are protective against ALD. Polyunsaturated fatty acids potentiate alcohol induced liver injury by inducing cytochromeP-450 2E1. Fatty acid saturation decreases CYP2E1 activity and lipid peroxidation in rat studies. Nanjiet al showed that when alcohol feeding was stopped in rats and the dietary fat was switched from fish oil rich in polyunsaturates to palm oil rich in saturated fatty acids, the alcohol induced liver injury was reversed to normal.42 When rats were fed fish oil continuously before and after alcohol withdrawal, the liver injury persisted. The role of fatty acids needs to be explored in human ALD.
Long term oxandrolone has been used because of its anabolic effects (improved nitrogen balance) and its ability to accelerate the reversal of the fatty liver of ALD.43 It has shown benefit only in moderate disease.
Soya bean lecithin is also a possibility because it can restore phosphatidyl choline levels and inhibit fibrosis in baboons who are fed alcohol.44
Thalidomide has been considered in alcoholic hepatitis because it has anti-TNF properties.
Survival after liver transplant for alcoholic cirrhosis is similar to or even better than for other end stage liver diseases. Because of the limited availability of liver transplants, using this option in the management of ALD has become highly emotive because the disease is self inflicted. Most centres demand that patients be abstinent for six months before transplantation. Many candidates are deemed unsuitable because of socioeconomic reasons, psychiatric problems, or coexistent alcoholic damage to other organs such as cardiomyopathy. A major worry is the recidivism rate after transplant. A recent study from Birmingham noted a significant recidivism rate with patients often returning to alcohol intake in the first year after transplant.45 These patients rapidly developed histological liver injury including fibrosis.
Royal Medical Benevolent Fund
St Bartholomew's Hospital Choral Society
St Bartholomew's Hospital Choral Society celebrates the millennium and their 35th anniversary with a concert at the Royal Albert Hall on 21 November 2000 in support of their chosen charity for 2000/2001, the Royal Medical Benevolent Fund. The choir will perform Mahler's Symphony No 8, “Symphony of a Thousand” with the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra. Six hundred singers are needed for this monumental work so contact the Barts Choir Honorary Secretary on 01628 664157 to participate. To support the Royal Medical Benevolent Fund contact the Fund at 24 King's Road, Wimbledon, London SW19 8QN (tel: 020 8540 9194, fax: 020 8542 0494, e-mail:).